I read an article about two months ago (that I just spent an hour trying to dig up in Google- if you think you found it, please leave a link in the comments!) that talked about the difference between the start of the Slow Food movement in America, and in Italy. In Italy, apparently, it’s fairly common to think that the right thing to do is the pleasurable thing to do. I know that with my working class Irish and Scottish roots, pleasure was seen as suspect, dangerous, and probably immoral.
That lead me to meditate on the nature of pleasure and morality. I am starting to think that genuine pleasure is, in fact, a moral compass pointing to that which is good, right, and wholesome- this is a remarkable change from some internalized messages about suffering being good for you, and work being something you did with honor, and the harder you worked (and the less you got paid) the more pure the work was. I remember getting the distinct impression that working all day as a ditch digger was more right than working all day in an air conditioned office, and that the misery of the toil was proportionate to how much you got paid. If you were in an office, it was better to work for a boss you hated at a job you loathed than some place that made you happy. The more you suffered the more you proved… what? That you could put up with crap to feed your family? That you were willing to martyr yourself on the altar of the Almighty Dollar?
Being that I don’t particularly enjoy being miserable and I’m not interested in martyrdom, I developed a deep suspicion of work in general and jobs in particular, with a fairly low fuck-this-I’m-out-of-here threshold. If I worked for myself, I could at least prevent myself from being ground into nothing for pennies. I have no interest in being one of the faceless workers in a Diego Rivera mural.
Upon further reflection, though, I don’t think that view of work is correct. It makes tolerating the absence of pleasure a virtue, because pleasure itself is suspect. However, if pleasure points us in the direction of virtue, why is there this deep distrust of pleasure in our culture?
I think that true pleasure has been co-opted or makes by lots of other things in our culture. Fast food is not pleasurable, but it is convenient, and when I look around me I see convenience has taken the place of pleasure in many lives. I know there are other things that have probably taken over healthy pleasure (gluttony is not pleasure, as someone who’s recovering from an eating disorder where there was a lot of overeating involved I can tell you that it’s a pretty miserable sensation, physically), or tried to take over pleasure.
I am thinking of pleasure that leads to a deep satisfaction, and yet even in my head I have a hard time teasing that out from the instantaneous associations with sex. What I am talking about it not sex, although that seems to be the only pleasure or satisfaction that is ever talked about. I’m talking about something more, something grander- the joy of being alive, of being a healthy animal. The enjoyment of a friends company, a good beer on a warm day, a peach at the peak of ripeness, sweet and warm with the sun’s touch, fresh off the tree, and making the kiddo laugh are all things that are fantastically pleasurable to me, and they bring me a lot of joy. There’s a lot of pleasure in things that I normally don’t think of as pleasurable, too. I do really enjoy some kinds of cleaning, because the results are so wonderful to live with. If you don’t believe me, think about the lovely sensation of slipping between cool, freshly laundered sheets that smell faintly of good lavender. Doing work with a defined end, that creates order and a place of calm in my otherwise chaotic and disordered life, is tremendously satisfying.
There’s also an element of untangling fun from happiness. I know you can buy distraction and fun, but fun is short lived. Happiness, for me, was always something deeper. I think the short, shallow, satisfactionles pleasure and fun drive a lot of consumer dollars.
And yet, for me, the very concept of pleasure that leads to joy has such tight bonds with sex and negative, dark things that I just know I’m going to have to spend a lot of time untangling that little bit of programming that I somehow managed to internalize. I want pleasure to be about things that bring me a genuine lightness in my heart, things that delight the senses and make me feel glad to be alive. I want that to surround as many moments of my life as I can manage.
I think I’ve been taught to short change joy. When I look around, I think it’s cultural, and I wonder who started it, and if it’s just me.
I think I need to reclaim pleasure as a worthy moral compass.